Skip to main content

Deterministic Transaction Fees

Transactions currently include a fee field that indicates the maximum fee field a slot leader is permitted to charge to process a transaction. The cluster, on the other hand, agrees on a minimum fee. If the network is congested, the slot leader may prioritize the transactions offering higher fees. That means the client won't know how much was collected until the transaction is confirmed by the cluster and the remaining balance is checked. It smells of exactly what we dislike about Ethereum's "gas", non-determinism.

Congestion-driven fees#

Each validator uses signatures per slot (SPS) to estimate network congestion and SPS target to estimate the desired processing capacity of the cluster. The validator learns the SPS target from the genesis config, whereas it calculates SPS from recently processed transactions. The genesis config also defines a target lamports_per_signature, which is the fee to charge per signature when the cluster is operating at SPS target.

Calculating fees#

The client uses the JSON RPC API to query the cluster for the current fee parameters. Those parameters are tagged with a blockhash and remain valid until that blockhash is old enough to be rejected by the slot leader.

Before sending a transaction to the cluster, a client may submit the transaction and fee account data to an SDK module called the fee calculator. So long as the client's SDK version matches the slot leader's version, the client is assured that its account will be changed exactly the same number of lamports as returned by the fee calculator.

Fee Parameters#

In the first implementation of this design, the only fee parameter is lamports_per_signature. The more signatures the cluster needs to verify, the higher the fee. The exact number of lamports is determined by the ratio of SPS to the SPS target. At the end of each slot, the cluster lowers lamports_per_signature when SPS is below the target and raises it when above the target. The minimum value for lamports_per_signature is 50% of the target lamports_per_signature and the maximum value is 10x the target `lamports_per_signature'

Future parameters might include:

  • lamports_per_pubkey - cost to load an account
  • lamports_per_slot_distance - higher cost to load very old accounts
  • lamports_per_byte - cost per size of account loaded
  • lamports_per_bpf_instruction - cost to run a program


Hijacking the SPS Target#

A group of validators can centralize the cluster if they can convince it to raise the SPS Target above a point where the rest of the validators can keep up. Raising the target will cause fees to drop, presumably creating more demand and therefore higher TPS. If the validator doesn't have hardware that can process that many transactions that fast, its confirmation votes will eventually get so long that the cluster will be forced to boot it.